Independent motor engineering evidence for RTA litigation
Independent technical opinions for claimants, defendants, insurers and single joint expert instructions. In litigation, sound evidence matters more than a preferred outcome, and our qualified experts recognise their duty to the court.
Independent expertise, regardless of who instructs us
Motor engineering expertise for your cases
Explore the areas in which our engineers can assist, subject to the scope of instruction and available evidence.
A straightforward instruction process
Designed to help solicitors establish proportionate scope and keep litigation moving.
Define the issue
Tell us the technical questions, vehicle details, deadlines and whether the matter is for advice, litigation or a single joint expert.
Review the evidence
We agree what is available and sufficient, such as repair estimates, images, valuations, inspection records and relevant court directions.
Receive an independent opinion
A suitably qualified engineer prepares findings, assumptions and limitations. Further inspection is recommended where desktop evidence is insufficient.
Independence is fundamental to credible expert evidence
An independent motor engineering report is valuable because it addresses what the evidence shows, rather than what the claimant, defendant, insurer or instructing solicitor would prefer it to show. We have no financial interest in whether the repair cost or vehicle value is higher or lower. Our engineers must be willing to reach and explain a conclusion that may not favour the party paying for the report.
For expert evidence in civil proceedings in England and Wales, CPR Part 35 makes the expert's duty to help the court on matters within their expertise paramount to any obligation to the person instructing or paying them. That applies equally when Laird is instructed by a claimant, a defendant, an insurer or as a single joint expert. A robust expert explains the evidence, the reasoning, any alternative explanations and material limitations, not simply an assertion of opinion.
This distinction matters commercially as well as legally: instructions founded on impartial analysis are better placed to withstand scrutiny, negotiation and cross-examination. We consider available photographs, estimates, manufacturer information and market evidence, and recommend further documents, physical inspection or testing when an informed conclusion cannot responsibly be reached from a desktop review.
A routine engineering assessment is not automatically a CPR Part 35 expert report. We agree the purpose of an instruction, questions, applicable declarations and court directions before preparing a report intended as expert evidence.
Questions from RTA solicitors
Practical answers when instructing a motor engineering expert.
Our engineers assess the technical evidence without a financial interest in the repair cost, valuation or preferred claim outcome. For CPR Part 35 evidence in England and Wales, the expert's overriding duty is to the court rather than the person who instructs or pays them.
Yes. An expert opinion must reflect the available evidence and the expert's reasoned analysis, even where that conclusion does not support the instructing party's position. Material assumptions and limitations are identified.
Yes, subject to relevant expertise, conflicts checks, suitable instructions and availability. We can also consider single joint expert instructions where appropriate.
Sometimes. Valuation and repair-cost questions can often be examined from suitable records, but hidden damage, workmanship or causation issues may require a physical inspection or further investigation. We will explain where the evidence is insufficient.
The questions requiring expert opinion, relevant vehicle and incident details, available photographs, estimates, invoices, earlier reports, litigation timetable and any court order or directions. We will identify further evidence needed.
Fees and timescales depend on complexity, document volume, inspection requirements and court deadlines. We scope the work and provide an estimate before an instruction is accepted.
Need independent engineering evidence for a motor claim?
Tell us the legal questions, available evidence and deadline. We will confirm whether we can assist and the likely scope of work.